Intro To Philosophy Quiz Part- IV

Reviewed by Editorial Team
The ProProfs editorial team is comprised of experienced subject matter experts. They've collectively created over 10,000 quizzes and lessons, serving over 100 million users. Our team includes in-house content moderators and subject matter experts, as well as a global network of rigorously trained contributors. All adhere to our comprehensive editorial guidelines, ensuring the delivery of high-quality content.
Learn about Our Editorial Process
| By Catherine Halcomb
Catherine Halcomb
Community Contributor
Quizzes Created: 1443 | Total Attempts: 6,714,115
| Attempts: 551 | Questions: 20
Please wait...
Question 1 / 20
0 %
0/100
Score 0/100
1. According to Rachels, the Same-Body Theory is threatened by the claim that the new Ship of Theseus is not numerically identical to the old Ship of Theseus.

Explanation

Rachels argues that the Same-Body Theory, which states that an object remains the same as long as it retains the same physical body, is challenged by the claim that the new Ship of Theseus is not numerically identical to the old Ship of Theseus. This means that according to Rachels, the new ship cannot be considered the same as the old ship, contradicting the Same-Body Theory. Therefore, the statement "True" accurately reflects Rachels' position on this matter.

Submit
Please wait...
About This Quiz
Metaphysics Quizzes & Trivia

This 'Intro to Philosophy Quiz Part- IV' explores key metaphysical questions about personal identity, examining theories like the Soul Theory and Bundle Theory, and discussing thought experiments such as the Ship of Theseus. It assesses understanding of complex philosophical concepts relevant to metaphysics.

2. According to Rachels, most philosophers today agree that the correct view of personal identity at a time is the Bundle Theory.

Explanation

According to Rachels, most philosophers today agree that the correct view of personal identity at a time is the Bundle Theory. Therefore, the statement "True" is the correct answer. The Bundle Theory suggests that personal identity is not defined by a single substance or essence, but rather by a collection or bundle of different experiences, memories, and characteristics that make up an individual at a specific point in time. This theory rejects the notion of a fixed and unchanging self, emphasizing the dynamic and ever-changing nature of personal identity.

Submit
3. According to Rachels, if you don't remember anything about certain actions in the past, then you're not responsible for those past actions.

Explanation

According to Rachels, if you don't remember anything about certain actions in the past, then you're not responsible for those past actions. This suggests that memory plays a crucial role in determining responsibility for past actions. If there is no recollection or awareness of the actions, it is difficult to hold someone accountable for them. Therefore, the statement is true.

Submit
4. Rachels raises the following objection to the Same-Brain Theory.  Suppose a healthy person drowns over a 10-minute period.  After those 10 minutes, the person no longer exists, but their brain is still there.  So the same brain isn't the same person. TRUE OR FALSE: Our reply in the Lecture to this objection is that the Same-Brain Theory is meant to exclude brains that are non-functioning because of death.

Explanation

The correct answer is True. In the lecture, the reply to Rachels' objection is that the Same-Brain Theory is specifically referring to functioning brains. When a person drowns and their brain is still intact but non-functioning due to death, it is not considered the same person according to the Same-Brain Theory. Therefore, the Same-Brain Theory does not contradict Rachels' objection.

Submit
5. According to the Lecture, if the Same-Soul Theory is true, and your soul becomes attached to the body of a pig when you die, but you lose your personality and instead have the personality of a pig, you still have survived the death of your body.

Explanation

If the Same-Soul Theory is true and your soul becomes attached to the body of a pig after death, it means that your consciousness or essence continues to exist in a different form. Even though you lose your human personality and acquire the personality of a pig, the fact that your soul survives and transitions into another body implies that you have indeed survived the death of your original body.

Submit
6. In the Lecture, OUR reply to Rachels' Ship of Theseus  objection to the Same Body Theory is that the new ship is the same as the old one

Explanation

The explanation for the given correct answer is that in the lecture, the speaker provided a response to Rachels' objection to the Same Body Theory by stating that the new ship is considered the same as the old one. This implies that despite the replacement of parts or components, the ship retains its identity and continuity. Therefore, the answer is true.

Submit
7. Identical twins are numerically identical with each other.

Explanation

Identical twins are not numerically identical with each other. While they may share the same DNA and physical characteristics, they are still two separate individuals with their own unique identities. The term "identical" refers to their genetic makeup, not their numerical identity. Therefore, the statement is false.

Submit
8. According to Rachels, memory doesn't always go along with responsibility for this reason:

Explanation

According to Rachels, memory doesn't always go along with responsibility because it is possible to accurately remember committing a crime but not be responsible for it. This suggests that memory alone is not sufficient to determine responsibility for an act. Other factors such as intention, knowledge, and control over one's actions must also be considered. Therefore, a person may have committed a crime but not be morally or legally responsible for it if they were coerced, manipulated, or lacked the capacity to understand the consequences of their actions.

Submit
9. According to Rachels, you are always responsible for what you've done.

Explanation

According to Rachels, you are not always responsible for what you've done. He argues that there are situations where a person's actions may not be considered morally blameworthy, such as when they are coerced or acting under duress. Therefore, the statement that you are always responsible for what you've done is false according to Rachels.

Submit
10. The point of Locke's Prince and Cobbler story is to show:

Explanation

Locke's Prince and Cobbler story is used to illustrate a problem with the Same-Body Theory. This theory suggests that personal identity is based on the continuity of the same physical body over time. However, Locke argues that even if the memories and consciousness of the Prince were transferred into the body of the Cobbler, the Prince's personal identity would not transfer with it. This challenges the Same-Body Theory and suggests that personal identity is not solely dependent on the physical body, but also on the continuity of consciousness and memories.

Submit
11. The results of the experiments done on split-brain patients indicate to Derek Parfit that the number of selves in a person is:

Explanation

The experiments done on split-brain patients involve severing the connection between the left and right hemispheres of the brain. This results in the two hemispheres functioning independently, leading to the observation that each hemisphere can have its own separate consciousness. However, Derek Parfit argues that these observations do not imply the existence of multiple selves. Instead, he suggests that the concept of a unified self is an illusion and that there is ultimately no fixed number of selves in a person. Therefore, the correct answer is "None."

Submit
12. Rachels discusses the riddle of the Ship of Theseus because he thinks it undermines:

Explanation

Rachels discusses the riddle of the Ship of Theseus because he believes it challenges the idea of the Same-Body Theory. The Ship of Theseus is a thought experiment that questions whether an object remains the same when all its parts are replaced over time. This challenges the Same-Body Theory, which suggests that an object's identity is determined by its physical body. If the Ship of Theseus can still be considered the same ship after all its parts have been replaced, then the Same-Body Theory is undermined.

Submit
13. Suppose the Memory Theory is true. Then the following is true.

Explanation

The given answer states that according to the Memory Theory, one can only survive the death of their body if there exists a future body that possesses their memories. This suggests that memories are crucial for the continuation of one's existence beyond physical death. Without the presence of memories in a future body, survival is not possible. This explanation aligns with the concept of the Memory Theory and provides a logical understanding of the statement.

Submit
14. While considering the Soul Theory of personal identity over time, Rachels says that:

Explanation

The given answer suggests that according to Rachels, the main issue with the Soul Theory of personal identity over time is that it is not clear how we would be able to determine if the same soul exists at different points in time. This is because souls cannot be observed with the senses. Rachels argues that since we cannot directly perceive or observe souls, it becomes difficult to establish continuity of personal identity based on the existence of a soul.

Submit
15. According to Rachels, responsibility doesn't always go with identity for the following reason:

Explanation

According to Rachels, responsibility doesn't always go with identity because it is possible for someone to have committed a crime but not be responsible for it. This can occur in situations where the person committed the crime under duress or coercion, or if they were not mentally capable of understanding the consequences of their actions. In such cases, although the person may have physically carried out the crime, they cannot be held morally responsible for their actions.

Submit
16. Hume rejects the Soul Theory for the following reason:

Explanation

Hume rejects the Soul Theory because he argues that we never observe souls. According to him, all our knowledge comes from our senses and impressions, and since we cannot directly perceive or observe the existence of souls, we have no reason to believe in them. Hume emphasizes the importance of empirical evidence and rejects any claims that cannot be verified through observation or experience. Therefore, the idea of having the same soul at different times is dismissed by Hume due to the lack of observable evidence.

Submit
17. According to Rachels, the Bundle Theory asserts that you have a simple and indivisible self that is present throughout your life.

Explanation

According to Rachels, the Bundle Theory actually denies the existence of a simple and indivisible self that persists throughout one's life. Instead, it suggests that a person is simply a collection or bundle of experiences, thoughts, and sensations. Therefore, the correct answer is False.

Submit
18. According to Rachels, the Memory-Links Theory works well for real memories and for apparent memories.

Explanation

According to Rachels, the Memory-Links Theory does not work well for real memories and for apparent memories.

Submit
19. The reply we make in the Lecture to Rachels' cell-regeneration objection to the Same-Body Theory is this:

Explanation

not-available-via-ai

Submit
20. Thomas Reid gives the following objection to the Memory Theory:

Explanation

Thomas Reid's objection to the Memory Theory is that it denies the identity between the general and the boy who stole the flag. According to the Memory Theory, personal identity is determined by memory continuity. However, in this case, the general and the boy who stole the flag are considered to be the same person, even though they have no memory continuity. Therefore, the Memory Theory cannot account for this identity, which is why Reid objects to it.

Submit
View My Results

Quiz Review Timeline (Updated): Mar 21, 2023 +

Our quizzes are rigorously reviewed, monitored and continuously updated by our expert board to maintain accuracy, relevance, and timeliness.

  • Current Version
  • Mar 21, 2023
    Quiz Edited by
    ProProfs Editorial Team
  • Dec 15, 2020
    Quiz Created by
    Catherine Halcomb
Cancel
  • All
    All (20)
  • Unanswered
    Unanswered ()
  • Answered
    Answered ()
According to Rachels, the Same-Body Theory is threatened by the claim...
According to Rachels, most philosophers today agree that the correct...
According to Rachels, if you don't remember anything about certain...
Rachels raises the following objection to the Same-Brain Theory. ...
According to the Lecture, if the Same-Soul Theory is true, and your...
In the Lecture, OUR reply to Rachels' Ship of Theseus ...
Identical twins are numerically identical with each other.
According to Rachels, memory doesn't always go along with...
According to Rachels, you are always responsible for what you've...
The point of Locke's Prince and Cobbler story is to show:
The results of the experiments done on split-brain patients indicate...
Rachels discusses the riddle of the Ship of Theseus because he thinks...
Suppose the Memory Theory is true. Then the following is true.
While considering the Soul Theory of personal identity over time,...
According to Rachels, responsibility doesn't always go with...
Hume rejects the Soul Theory for the following reason:
According to Rachels, the Bundle Theory asserts that you have a simple...
According to Rachels, the Memory-Links Theory works well for real...
The reply we make in the Lecture to Rachels' cell-regeneration...
Thomas Reid gives the following objection to the Memory Theory:
Alert!

Advertisement