Ethics Quiz 5 - Due April 4, 2013

1. The statement "don't deceive a trusting audience with manipulated reality and don't offend an unsuspecting audience with your gritty reality" is an application of what ethical theory?

The Golden Mean rule.

Kant's Categorical Imperative.

The Utilitarian Model.

Potter's Box.

The statement "don't deceive a trusting audience with manipulated reality and don't offend an unsuspecting audience with your gritty reality" aligns with Kant's Categorical Imperative. This ethical theory emphasizes the importance of treating others as ends in themselves, rather than as a means to an end. It promotes the idea of universal moral principles that should guide our actions, regardless of the consequences. In this case, the statement highlights the importance of honesty and respect towards the audience, which resonates with Kant's emphasis on treating others with dignity and not manipulating or deceiving them.

Explanation

The statement "don't deceive a trusting audience with manipulated reality and don't offend an unsuspecting audience with your gritty reality" aligns with Kant's Categorical Imperative. This ethical theory emphasizes the importance of treating others as ends in themselves, rather than as a means to an end. It promotes the idea of universal moral principles that should guide our actions, regardless of the consequences. In this case, the statement highlights the importance of honesty and respect towards the audience, which resonates with Kant's emphasis on treating others with dignity and not manipulating or deceiving them.

2. True or false? Jump cuts in a video interview or splicing together different statements to take the original interview or statements out of context is a new media approach that is quite ethical.

True

False

Jump cuts in a video interview or splicing together different statements to take the original interview or statements out of context is not an ethical approach in new media. This practice can distort the intended message, mislead the audience, and manipulate the narrative. It is important to present information accurately and in context to maintain ethical standards in media.

Explanation

Jump cuts in a video interview or splicing together different statements to take the original interview or statements out of context is not an ethical approach in new media. This practice can distort the intended message, mislead the audience, and manipulate the narrative. It is important to present information accurately and in context to maintain ethical standards in media.

3. What factors would you consider on whether or not to take certain photos from a gruesome scene of a crime or accident?

Should the moment be made public?

Will the photo send subjects into further trauma?

Are you at the least obtrusive distance possible?

Are you acting with compassion and sensitivity?

None of the above.

All of the above.

The question asks about the factors to consider when deciding whether or not to take certain photos from a gruesome scene of a crime or accident. The correct answer is "All of the above," which means that all the factors mentioned in the question should be taken into consideration. These factors include whether the moment should be made public, if the photo will cause further trauma to the subjects, if the photographer is at the least obtrusive distance possible, and if they are acting with compassion and sensitivity. Considering all these factors ensures ethical and responsible photography in such sensitive situations.

Explanation

The question asks about the factors to consider when deciding whether or not to take certain photos from a gruesome scene of a crime or accident. The correct answer is "All of the above," which means that all the factors mentioned in the question should be taken into consideration. These factors include whether the moment should be made public, if the photo will cause further trauma to the subjects, if the photographer is at the least obtrusive distance possible, and if they are acting with compassion and sensitivity. Considering all these factors ensures ethical and responsible photography in such sensitive situations.

4. What are two concerns that a photojournalist must consider when taking a picture for a news event and publishing it?

A photojournalist should consider whether there is an alternative for capturing a scene that may be too gruesome to show.

A photojournalist has no ethical concerns if the victim is dead.

Individuals have concerns about protecting their "personal space" and preserving their private information, such as grieving.

None of the above.

A photojournalist must consider the concerns of individuals about protecting their "personal space" and preserving their private information, such as grieving. This implies that the photojournalist should respect the privacy and emotions of the people involved in the news event. It is important for the photojournalist to balance the need to capture and report the news with the ethical responsibility of not causing harm or invading the privacy of individuals.

Explanation

A photojournalist must consider the concerns of individuals about protecting their "personal space" and preserving their private information, such as grieving. This implies that the photojournalist should respect the privacy and emotions of the people involved in the news event. It is important for the photojournalist to balance the need to capture and report the news with the ethical responsibility of not causing harm or invading the privacy of individuals.

5. In publishing photographs of a gruesome scene or other very private facts, what are some of the factors that Warren Bovee lists to determine whether the ends justify the means? Pick all of the correct answers.

You must consider Kant's Categorical Imperative.

Are the means morally evil or merely distasteful?

The ends -- that is, breaking the news -- always justifies the means.

Is it possible that the means will achieve the end?

The correct answers are "Are the means morally evil or merely distasteful?" and "Is it possible that the means will achieve the end?" These factors listed by Warren Bovee are important in determining whether the ends justify the means when publishing photographs of a gruesome scene or other private facts. By considering whether the means are morally evil or distasteful, one can assess the ethical implications of the actions. Additionally, evaluating the possibility of the means achieving the desired end helps determine the effectiveness and justification of the actions taken.

Explanation

The correct answers are "Are the means morally evil or merely distasteful?" and "Is it possible that the means will achieve the end?" These factors listed by Warren Bovee are important in determining whether the ends justify the means when publishing photographs of a gruesome scene or other private facts. By considering whether the means are morally evil or distasteful, one can assess the ethical implications of the actions. Additionally, evaluating the possibility of the means achieving the desired end helps determine the effectiveness and justification of the actions taken.

Submit