- #1

- 1,681

- 3

I began by saying "yes", then changed to "no" because of the way the equation was derived. (It was derived by bringing together N=2 or more charges and ignoring the self-energy of each electron.)

I now wish to change my answer back to "yes", that the equation still works even for a single electron though the volume limits of integration (and therefore the exact value of the energy) is not known.

My argument is that it can be applied to the three quarks in the proton. From a great distance the proton an electron have the same charge and therefore you should be able to integrate the energy density of the electron according to the above equation at least up the exclusion of a sphere of protonic radius. The field energy of the electron should be at least this great and probably greater since it is smaller in size than the proton.