Is the following situation Valid or Invalid? 1. My teacher Mr. Hill - ProProfs Discuss
Advertisement

Is the following situation Valid or Invalid? 1. My teacher Mr. Hill is a jackass.
2. All jackasses have long ears. Therefore, my teacher Mr. Hill has long ears.


Asked by Alderney, Last updated: Mar 27, 2024

+ Answer
Request
Question menu
Vote up Vote down

2 Answers

felicitas

felicitas

felicitas
Felicitas

Answered Oct 24, 2017

Invalid because the premise does not follow the conclusion therefore it is invalid.

upvote downvote
Reply 

John Smith

John Smith

John Smith
John Smith

Answered Sep 08, 2016

Invalid-invalid. if the meaning of jackass was the same in both premises then it would be valid. but clearly were using the term in two different senses in each of the premises. in the first premise were using jackass metaphorically, as an insult. in the second premise were using it literally, to refer to a type of animal with long ears. since these terms no longer refer to the same thing, the logic is broken and the conclusion doesnt follow.arguments like this commit the fallacy known as equivocation, which involves using the same term with two different meanings in an argument. here wed say that this argument equivocates on the meaning of jackass.
upvote downvote
Reply 

Advertisement
Advertisement
Search for Google images Google Image Icon
Select a recommended image
Upload from your computer Loader
Image Preview
Search for Google images Google Image Icon
Select a recommended image
Upload from your computer Loader
Image Preview
Search for Google images Google Image Icon
Select a recommended image
Upload from your computer Loader

Email Sent
We have sent an email to your address "" with instructions to reset your password.