Jeff and David's grandfather
A silver spur and an old copy of the Cabin Creek Gazette
A candy wrapper left by the McCoys
The hidden treasure
He ran away from them before they could ask him any questions.
He was walking with a limp in the library but was not when he was at his car.
He was acting very nervous.
He began to yell at them for following him.
They started to not like her and didn't want her help.
They felt like her dog Yum Yum was too big to fit in the boat.
They wanted to explore the island their way without worrying about what Claire wanted to do.
She said she didn't want to go with them today.
They went so far in the cave they got lost
Their flashlights fell in the water and they couldn't find their way out.
The entryway was suddenly barricaded.
They decided they wanted to camp out for the night.
The boys flashlight
A letter from Mr. Wellbacks great grandfather that proved he was a hero
Candy that was dropped by the McCoys proving they were spying on them
The investigators report
The silver spur