Once existed in the United States were two unions of Labor, which were the American Federation of Labor (AFL) and the Knights of Labor. The American Federation of Labor happened to be a formal association of the labor unions, whereas the knights of Labor seemed to be a more secretive one. The knights of Labor, in addition, was a more radical association. James L. Wright and Uriah Smith Stephens formed a secret union in 1869, which is referred to as the noble family of the Knights of Labor.
This is actually the basis for the formation of the Knights of Labor. Stephens was once the leader of the organization before Terence V. took up the leadership position and made the organization have national recognition. After some time, the Knights of Labor lost its recognition as its membership declined due to autocratic structure, unsuccessful strikes, and mismanagement. When the Knights of Labor lost its recognition, the AFL gain popularity after its formation in 1886 at Columbus, Ohio.
Tara Pele, Technical Blogger, MCA from New York, New York
Answered Oct 03, 2019
The Knight of Labor and the AFL (American Federation of Labor) are two different labor organizations in the United States of America. In 1869, the Knight of Labor was formed as a secret group by Uriah Smith Stephens and James Wright. Knight of Labor operated in the United States and in Canada. Lawyers, stockholders, and a lot more groups of people were not allowed to be part of the Knight of Labor.
In 1886, the American Federation of Labor was formed by leaders such as Samuel Gompers, William Green, George Meany, and John McBride. It is launched as a much more formal organization compared to the Knight of Labor. American Federation of Labor was launched in the United States in Columbus, Ohio. The American Federation of Labor only gained much popularity after there was a great decline in the Knight of Labor.
The Knights of Labour and AFL are different labor Unions that existed in the United States. Knight of Labour was created in 1869. It was secretly formed by Uriah Smith Stephen and James L. Wright. The union was only recognized on the national level when Terence Powderly took over the leadership of the union. Coal miners of Pennsylvania were popular members of the union.
AFL which stands for American Federation of Labour was established in 1886 in Columbus, Ohio. Gompers and Peter J.McGuire were strong founding members of the union. The union was more of a federal union unlike the Knight of Labor that was secretive at the initial stage. AFL union became popular after the decline of the Knight of Labour. Hope you find this information helpful.
The Knights of Labor and AFL (American Federation of Labor) are divergent labor unions which have been here in the United States. The AFL was a traditional federation of labor unions, while Knights of Labor was far more private. One of the significant differences between the Knights of Labor and the AFL is that the former one was more extremist.
The development of Knights of Labor can be traced back to the Noble Order of the Knights of Labor, which was a secret union that formed in 1869. This union became popular amidst the coal miners of Pennsylvania during the economic depression of the 1870s. Also, upon the end of this time, the Knights of Labor established itself as a leading labor union, which enacted many demands, such as ending convict labor and child labor.
Knights of Labor and American Federation of Labor also known as AFL are two types of labor unions that are available in the United States. The AFL is considered to be the more formal type of union while Knights of Labor is known to be more private and more secretive. Those who are part of the Knights of Labor are said to think in a more radical manner.
The AFL was started in the year 1886. The Knights of Labor was started three years later. People can become part of one or the other. Knights of Labor was more popular in the beginning but it started to decline because of various reasons. With its loss of popularity, the AFL started to become more known.
It should be known that Knights of Labor and American Federation of Labor are different from each other. Both labor unions are present in the United States. The AFL is known to be a federation of the different unions that are available. The Knights of Labor is known to be more secretive.
There are people who were not allowed to be part of Knights of Labor such as the Chinese, lawyers, stockholders, and so much more. They were considered to be unproductive and undeserving to be part of the union. Some of these people decided to become part of the American Federation of Labor instead.